SanctionsLookup

Data last synced:

ZTE OFAC Settlement: $100.9M (2017)

Last updated:

Zhongxing Telecommunications Equipment Corporation, a telecommunications corporation established in the People's Republic of China, and its subsidiaries and affiliates, as well as ZTE Kangxun Telecommunications Ltd. and its subsidiaries and affiliates (collectively "ZTE"), settled their potential civil liability for 251 apparent violations of the Iranian Transactions and Sanctions Regulations, 31 C.F.R. part 560, in the amount of $100,871,266.

Penalty Amount

$100,871,266.00

Enforcement Date

March 7, 2017

Rank in Top Penalties

#17

Case Details

Type:
Entity
Name:
Zhongxing Telecommunications Equipment Corporation
Country:
People's Republic of China
Industry:
Telecom
Address:
People's Republic of China
Penalty amount:
$100,871,266.00
Base civil monetary penalty:
$106,180,280.00
Max civil monetary penalty:
$106,180,280.00
Egregious case:
Yes
Apparent violations:
251
Voluntary self disclosure:
No
Case:
Settlement
Violation period:
January 2010 to March 2016
Program:
Iranian Transactions and Sanctions Regulations, 31 C.F.R. part 560 (ITSR)
Enforcement date:
March 7, 2017

Nature of the Apparent Violations

From on or about January 2010 to on or about March 2016, ZTE engaged in: (i) the exportation, sale, or supply, directly or indirectly, from the United States of goods to Iran or the Government of Iran; (ii) the reexportation of controlled U.S.-origin goods subject to the Export Administration Regulations from a third-country with knowledge that the goods were intended specifically for Iran or the Government of Iran; and (iii) activity that evaded or avoided, attempted and/or conspired to violate, and/or caused violations of the prohibitions set forth in the ITSR. ZTE appears to have engaged in 251 transactions in apparent violation of §§ 560.203, 560.204, and/or 560.205 of the ITSR. The total value of the transactions constituting the apparent violations was $39,622,972.

ZTE's highest-level management developed, approved, and implemented a company-wide plan that utilized third-party companies to conceal and facilitate ZTE's illegal business with Iran. ZTE's highest-level management was specifically aware of and considered the legal risks of engaging in such activities prior to signing contracts with Iranian customers and supplying U.S.-origin goods to Iran. Essential to the performance of such contracts was ZTE's procurement of and delivery to Iran of U.S.-origin goods, including goods controlled for anti-terrorism, national security, regional stability, and encryption item purposes. Pursuant to its contracts with Iranian customers, ZTE was required to and did in fact enhance the law enforcement surveillance capabilities and features of Iran's telecommunications facilities and infrastructure.

ZTE's unlawful business activities with Iran were publicly disclosed in a media report in 2012. Shortly thereafter, ZTE learned of the U.S. government's investigation into the company's business activities with Iran. ZTE subsequently communicated to the U.S. government that it had wound down and ceased its Iran-related activities. However, ZTE's highest-level leadership decided to surreptitiously resume its Iran-related business in 2013, which it continued until 2016, when the Department of Commerce suspended the company's export privileges by adding it to the Entity List. Under the direction of its leadership, ZTE deleted evidence and provided the U.S. government with altered information to hide the fact that it had resumed its unlawful business with Iran.

How OFAC Determined the Penalty

OFAC determined that ZTE did not voluntarily self-disclose the apparent violations to OFAC and that the apparent violations constitute an egregious case. Both the base civil monetary penalty and statutory maximum civil monetary penalty amounts for the apparent violations was $106,180,280. The settlement amount of $100,871,266 reflects OFAC's consideration of the facts and circumstances pursuant to the General Factors under OFAC's Enforcement Guidelines.

Aggravating Factors

  • ZTE willfully and recklessly demonstrated disregard for U.S. sanctions requirements in engaging in the egregious behavior that led to the apparent violations of U.S. economic sanctions laws. Various executives and senior executives knew or had reason to know of the conduct that led to the apparent violations and engaged in a long-term pattern of conduct designed to hide and purposefully obfuscate its conduct in order to mislead U.S. government investigators for several years. ZTE's conduct was the result of a widespread pattern or practice involving the coordination of many divisions and departments within the company.
  • ZTE had actual knowledge that the conduct giving rise to the apparent violations took place. The conduct was undertaken pursuant to directives and business processes that were illegitimate in nature and specifically designed and implemented to facilitate the violative behavior. ZTE had actual notice from multiple sources that both its initial business with Iran and its later resumption of business with Iran constituted or likely constituted a violation of U.S. economic sanctions laws, including, with respect to the later resumption of business with Iran, being the subject of a federal investigation at the time it decided to resume such activities, transactions, and its practices. ZTE's management played a key role in authorizing and carrying out the transactions at issue, and ZTE's senior leadership and management appear to have been involved with and possessed actual knowledge of the company's violative patterns and practices.
  • ZTE caused significant harm to the integrity of the ITSR and its associated policy objectives by engaging in the supply of a high volume and high value of U.S.-origin goods to Iran and the Government of Iran for several years, including items subject to the Commerce Control List for anti-terrorism, national security, regional stability, and encryption item reasons. ZTE systematically undermined the integrity of the sanctions program objectives, and conferred significant economic benefits to Iran and/or the Government of Iran.
  • ZTE is a sophisticated and experienced telecommunications company that has global operations and routinely deals in goods, services, and technology subject to U.S. laws.
  • From at least January 2010 to March 2016, ZTE's compliance program was either non-existent or unenforced.

Mitigating Factors

  • ZTE has not received a penalty notice or Finding of Violation from OFAC in the five years preceding the earliest transaction giving rise to the apparent violations.
  • ZTE cooperated with OFAC's investigation by executing three tolling agreements with OFAC for a total of 803 days. Beginning after March 2016, ZTE cooperated with OFAC's investigation by responding to requests for information, making witnesses available for interviews, providing data analytics regarding apparent violations, and submitting documentation associated with apparent violations of U.S. economic sanctions and export control laws committed by the company. ZTE took certain remedial steps in the final stages of the investigation in 2016 and 2017, including implementing an economic sanctions and export controls compliance program.

ZTE's settlement with OFAC is concurrent with a settlement agreement between ZTE and the Department of Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security, and ZTE's plea agreement (pending court approval) with the Department of Justice's National Security Division and U.S. Attorney's Office for the Northern District of Texas.

Official Source Documents

This page summarizes an OFAC enforcement case based on the document archived below. SanctionsLookup assumes no liability for errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the original documents, this summary, or any changes made to the source documents at any time.

Provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or compliance advice. Always consult the source document directly rather than relying on this summary.

Archived on June 13, 2026

SHA-256: 955c1180887affca99b700f066fae59a6d8d0b52a66152d8963269e1baff3e91

More OFAC Cases